Death penalty: Wrongful convictions and unfair sentencing in Malaysia

| September 09, 2017 |
Malaysia drug bust
Of over 1,100 currently on death row, many have not been afforded their right to representation and a fair trial.

While the death penalty in Malaysia is an issue that divides the nation and continues to be a hot topic in parliament, there is a group of people whose voices never enter the debate. They are the silent victims of this colonial-era law and the ones that pay the ultimate price for the errors of others - the wrongfully convicted.

Splitting public opinion pretty much down the middle, the death penalty in Malaysia is a hangover from British rule and is still the mandatory punishment for murder, drug trafficking, treason, and waging war against the King.

Last year, Malaysia executed 9 people - up from 1 the previous year - and handed down 36 death sentences. In its latest report on the issue, rights group Amnesty International ranked Malaysia 10th in the use of the death penalty among 23 countries where executions were recorded.

Human rights charities have repeatedly called on the country to abolish the practice altogether. Despite a years-long debate over amendments to the Dangerous Drugs Act of 1952 aimed at allowing judges to exercise discretion in sentencing for trafficking offences, little has been done.

In a statement in August following the most recent proposal to amend the laws, Legal Advisor at Human Rights Watch, Linda Lakhdhir called for decisive action from parliament.

Time for action

"The Malaysian government should stop playing games, and firmly commit now to introduce legislation in the next sitting of Parliament to eliminate the mandatory death penalty for all drug offenses - not just some drug offenses," she said.

"And while it is making changes to its policies on the death penalty, the government should also impose a moratorium on executions, and move swiftly to full abolition of the death penalty. Talk is cheap. It is time for action."

Despite mounting appeals, the punishment continues to be popular in a country that values the premise of "an eye for an eye". But of the over 1,100 currently on death row, many of them have not been afforded their right to representation and a fair trial, according to prominent defence lawyer at the National Legal Aid Foundation, Samantha Chong Yin Xin.

Speaking at the Freedom Film Festival in Kuala Lumpur, Chong explained how many of those convicted do not understand their rights and, in some cases, don't even know what they are being arrested for.

"Many people on death row do not have good legal representation," Chong explains. "Around 50 % of them are migrants which raises immediate issues with language. In a lot of cases, defendants don't even know what is happening when they are arrested and are not allowed to see a lawyer until sometimes 6 of 7 months after arrest."

"Locked in a your-word-against-mine situation with the police"

While some cases of wrongful or unfair conviction may receive media attention, the voice of this "silent group", as Chong calls them, are kept in the shadows, often left alone to fight the ultimate David vs Goliath battle against the police.

"In about 5 % of death penalty cases the witnesses are the police," Chong said. "In many cases we see policemen with zero principles but if the courts only have the word of the police against the word of the suspect, who are they going to believe? They will only reject police evidence if it's 'cow over the moon' type stuff."

This leaves many suspects in an impossible position; deprived of quality representation, not understanding the proceedings or their rights, and locked in a your-word-against-mine situation with the police.

Chong cites a case of a young Thai woman to demonstrate how common this treatment is.

When stopped on a bus on her way into the country, the young woman was asked by police officers if she owned the bag on the seat next to her. She said, no. Despite her denial, she was arrested and charged with drug trafficking after the bag was found to contain heroin.

After conviction, she found out that her statement had been falsified by police to say she claimed ownership of the bag. And the lawyer that defended her did not speak to her before the trial. Through incompetence and language barrier, she was not involved in the case at all, only to find later she was convicted and sentenced to death.

"It could be you who is in the wrong place at the wrong time. It's that simple."

Stories like that of this woman are not uncommon says Chong, and once a person has been convicted at the High Court level, there is little recourse. In Malaysia, appeals are made in Federal Court but, as Chong explains, the likelihood of the original conviction being overturned are incredibly slim.

"If you are convicted at High Court, your fate is sealed," Chong said. "The (Federal) Court's judgement is simple, 'You should have presented this (new argument) at High Court' and they will disallow it. I have never seen a successful case at Federal Court."

While some may look on death penalty cases with the attitude of "if you don't want to face the consequences, don't do the crime" or think the idea of a wrongful conviction is a nightmare that could never happen to them, Abdul Rashid Ismail, former president of the Malaysian Human Rights Society and solicitor, has a stark warning for all.

"We live in a system that's not perfect; witnesses make mistakes, police can be dishonest, judges are human beings, so mistakes can happen," he said.

"It can be any of us; your friend, your family, it could be you who is in the wrong place at the wrong time. It's that simple."

Source:, September 9, 2017

⚑ | Report an error, an omission, a typo; suggest a story or a new angle to an existing story; submit a piece, a comment; recommend a resource; contact the webmaster, contact us:

Opposed to Capital Punishment? Help us keep this blog up and running! DONATE!

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted." -- Oscar Wilde

from Death Penalty News

No comments:

Post a Comment

Back to Top